Is Alan Keyes Crazy?

November 18th, 2008, 5:40 PM EST

Alan Keyes is now behind an effort to deny Barack Obama California’s electoral votes.  On what basis, you ask?



The one-time presidential candidate who stopped by Illinois to challenge Obama for a senate seat in 2004 when the Republican Party couldn’t find anyone who actually lived in the state to run, believes documentary evidence is required to prove that President-elect Obama is a natural-born citizen.


Voila!


Responses to this post...

  1. Alan, I’m so glad you’re bringing this up. Keyes is off his rocker, as usual. The far right (Drudge and WorldNetDaily) continue to try and advance this story. It’s ridiculous. Again, the far right should remember that McCain was born in Panama which again, has nothing to do with requirements for POTUS. Enough already!

  2. Actually, being a natural born citizen is a requirement, and I accept both as being natural born citizens.

    “No person except a natural born citizen, or a citizen of the United States, at the time of the adoption of this Constitution, shall be eligible to the office of President; neither shall any person be eligible to that office who shall not have attained to the age of thirty five years, and been fourteen Years a resident within the United States.”

    http://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution/constitution.articleii.html

  3. As for the question Alan asked: probably.

  4. Being born a U.S. citizen has everything to do with the requirements to be POTUS.

    John McCain was born outside of the U.S. because his dad was in the military and stationed there at the time of John’s birth, which automatically makes him a citizen of the U.S.

    It’s funny how Obama went to Hawaii to visit his sick grandmother and then like majic his birth certificate was sealed so that nobody could see it. And, by the way, his grandmother died on the eve of the election and I do not think he even went to the funeral. What a guy.

  5. Alan Keyes is out there on the fringe, and provides an excellent example of everything that’s wrong with the Republican party.

    “…and then like majic his birth certificate was sealed…”

    Probably because the county clerk’s office couldn’t get any real work accomplished, and so decided “enough” with these lunatics.

    Posted by Rocky the Liberal Rottweiler
    November 18th, 2008 at 6:26 pm
  6. Who cares if Obama is a citizen? Bush is a crook, a liar and orchestrated the mass killing of innocent people in Iraq and that doesn’t seem to bother the right wingers.
    But if there may be talk about Obama not being a natural born citizen – why THAT’S AGAINST THE CONSTITUTION!

    Not any more Willy. The Bush/Cheney regime destroyed the constitution.

  7. Let me get this correct, Bush ordered the killing of innocent citizens. Did he also orchestrate 911, maybe katrina.
    TDRO, keep the coolaid flowing.

  8. My my my !!! Another hardcore right wing buffoon. Seems to me their must be a BUFFOONSVILLE USA somewhere out their. The pastor,that nut from Idaho,right wing talk show host,faux news and the beat goes on. I really believe their are aliens from space living among us.

  9. Seperate man,
    Innocent civilians died in the bombing of Iraq, (remember Shock and Awe), whether they were targeted or not. Many more died in the violence that followed, and in the landmines that are the result of cluster bombs.

    As for 9/11, Bush/Cheney were not interested in terrorism, because they were focused on missle shields, and invading Iraq.

    As for Katrina, they did nothing about the levees, and put an incompetent croney in charge of FEMA. After all, the 04 election was over, and they were just poor people who don’t vote for Republicans anyway.

  10. As for Katrina, they did nothing about the levees,

    Hi lefty. Could you elaborate on this point a little? Whos’ they and what is the inaction that you allude to? I’m not sure what you’re saying. Thanks

    Posted by trees are people too!
    November 18th, 2008 at 8:34 pm
  11. trees are people too, (why don’t caps take when you copy and paste?)

    LA Times reported in 04:

    Despite Warnings, Washington Failed to Fund Levee Projects
    By Nicole Gaouette and Richard A. Serrano
    September 04, 2005 in print edition A-1

    For years, Washington had been warned that doom lurked just beyond the levees. And for years, the White House and Congress had dickered over how much money to put into shoring up century-old dikes and carrying out newer flood control projects to protect the city of New Orleans.

    As recently as three months ago, the alarms were sounding – and being brushed aside.

    In late May, the New Orleans district of the Army Corps of Engineers formally notified Washington that hurricane storm surges could knock out two of the big pumping stations that must operate night and day even under normal conditions to keep the city dry.

  12. Ok, thanks. Was there any responsibility on the state government level, for maintenance and construction,or is the levy system entirely a federal government responsibility?

    I seem to remember something about funds that we’re earmarked for the levees being diverted to the development of casinos and gaming.

    p.s don’t worry about caps, I actually prefer the lower case.

    Posted by trees are people too!
    November 18th, 2008 at 9:16 pm
  13. To all of you who think a U.S. president does not need to be a natural-born citizen:

    It does matter; it is in the constitution. You can cry all you want about Bush destroying the constitution, (he didn’t) but it doesn’t matter. We still have one and if Obama is not a citizen, he isn’t qualified to be president. If the media had done their job as reporters, this story would have been researched and done with by now. There are consequences in not doing their jobs.

  14. TDro
    Who cares if Obama is a citizen? Bush is a crook, a liar and orchestrated the mass killing of innocent people in Iraq and that doesn’t seem to bother the right wingers.
    But if there may be talk about Obama not being a natural born citizen – why THAT’S AGAINST THE CONSTITUTION!

    Not any more Willy. The Bush/Cheney regime destroyed the constitution

    Who cares?! I care! A natural born US citizen is one of the requirements for the president as described in the constitution. Would you like to have an illegal immigrant to become the president or a man that came to this country to overthrow all the values that our nation stands for.(I’m not saying that this is what Obama is doing and that he has bad intentions.) And I would also like to hear how the Bush/Cheney administration destroyed the Constitution! And as you say that it would be ok for Obama to be the President even if he were not a US citizen just because, as you say, that Bush is a crook and a liar. How does that balance out?

  15. I have read it here 4 times—”Bush/Cheney distryoyed the constitution” I’m a little slow this evening can someone explain that to me.

  16. Well, let’s see. He spied on American citizens (beginning in January, 2001, before the bombing of the WTC), he tortured detainees, he lied to start a war with a sovreign nation so he could steal their oil, he outed a CIA agent, imprisoned an innocent democrat, fired 30+ attorneys general for political reasons, shall I continue?

    But let’s not concern ourselves with all these mindless petty crimes. We have bigger things to worry about – like whether these rumors about Obama not being a citizen are true.

    Gasp! That would be a terrible crime! Boy, and I thought Bush’s mindless killing of innocent men, women, children and American soldiers was bad! What was I thinking?

  17. By the way, Jeff, if you were so concerned about the constitution, you would be disgusted at the way it’s been treated by yuor Bush crime family.

  18. Re: Barack Obama’s birth certificate

    Please check Barack Obama’s birth certificate on factcheck.org, politifact.com and snopes.com.

    Posted by an american citizen
    November 18th, 2008 at 11:14 pm
  19. TDRO,
    And if you are so concerned with the constitution and its stability, you should be afraid of Obama because as he said the Constitution is something that is flawed to this day. And also if you were so concerned with the constitution, you would say that he should be a natural-born citizen because that is one of the three qualifications that a candidate must meet to become President of the United States. Your sarcastic comment of what a horrible crime it would be for Obama to be elected eventhough he is not a natural-born citizen tells me that you DO NOT support our Constitution because it would be against what the Constitution spells out in very simple words!

  20. I have just read the actual court filing in the challenge and it brings up several very lagitimate issues as to Obama’s status as a “natural born citizen”. I hope that he produces the appropriate documents and goes on to be one of our greatest Presidents. BUT if he cannot produce the proof he has no business being president. I thought this issue was all over with and settled but after reading the filing I am very concerned. Read the document!

  21. Jeff, you poor thing. The election is over friend, stop fighting a lost cause. All of the reputable fact checking sites have proven that his BC is legit. He’s as American as you and I. Please THINK friend, do you honestly think that the CIA, FBI, NIE and Home Land Security would allow Barack Obama to become the President of the US without knowing absolutely everything about him? Least of all weather he was a citizen or not. You’re DREAMING!! You’re grasping at straws friend, give it up you’ve guys lost!

    Posted by Classy Ginger
    November 18th, 2008 at 11:57 pm
  22. Alan, it sure didn’t take much work for you to find Obama’s birth cert.

    I am still in disbelief about the Rightwingers. They don’t give a damn what the truth is — they’re really living in a fantasy, parallel universe.

  23. Least of all weather he was a citizen or not.

    So you are not concerned that he might not be a natural-born citizen? It is true that the people elected him but does that mean that if he is not a natural-born citizen and that he does not qualify to be the President of The United States, that he should still become the President? It is defined in the Constitution that a candidate must be a NATURAL-BORN CITIZEN! So, if he turns out to be a fraud in December for lying about his citizenship, we should say that it is ok and that it was a flaw in the constitution that only a natural born citizen and with the other qualifications can become President?

  24. You know Allen, it was really Obama who couldn’t find anyone to run against after he had all his challengers disqualified from the ballot…but that’s for another day….Keyes is an idiot who does not come anywhere close to speaking for republicans….(come to think of it, who does?)….you can count the number of people who ever voted for him on one hand….

    TDRO….are you saying Bush spied on you the first month he was in office? Could you detail that please? And where exactly is all the oil he stole….I’d like to see it “redistributed”, as you folks call it….Valerie outted herslf (see Vanity Fair photo spread) she was hardly undercover…..that was the worst kept secret in D.C…..and her husband is unquestionable liar……

    Best of all, show me where it says the President can’t hire and fire his own U.S. Attorneys at will? And BTW, they were U.S. Attorneys, not Attorney Generals….but wait….before you answer that question, keep in mind the Clinton Crime Family fired ALL 93 U.S. Attorneys in their first year in office….

    Ok, now go ahead and explain to us how that violates the Constitution……

  25. Funny, barack Obut there is an actual BIRTH ANNOUNCEMENT for Barack Obama in both Hawaii newspapers dated from August of 1961.

    http://whatreallyhappened.com/IMAGES/obama-1961-birth-announcement-from-honolulu-advertiser0000.gif

    Read and cry right wing nuts. LOL

    Posted by Daniel Torluemke
    November 19th, 2008 at 12:43 am
  26. I guess Obama’s parents knew he would run for president one day so they placed this ad to cover it up for him in 2008!!! LOL

    Do right wing kooks have any idea what fools they are making of themselves?

    http://whatreallyhappened.com/IMAGES/obama-1961-birth-announcement-from-honolulu-advertiser0000.gif

    Posted by Daniel Torluemke
    November 19th, 2008 at 12:45 am
  27. Understand what your reading friend. I meant that knowing that he is a citizen would be one of the easiest things for them to find out. Do you think that they hadn’t heard the right whining about this birth certificate thing for some six month nows? What about the McCain campaign? Don’t you think they heard the far-right sniveling too? You don’t think the RNC had investigators looking into this in the hopes of saving McCain’s campaign? Think man! Are you a conspiracy theorist or have you lost your grasp on reality?

    Posted by Classy Ginger
    November 19th, 2008 at 12:48 am
  28. The government didn’t have any doubt about Obama being a citizen. But they knew they could dupe the right wing sheep into believing it vehemently so they spread seeds of doubt to encourage the people who were too ignorant to pay attention to the fact that he wasn’t disqualified in the primaries for that, and you know Hilary looked.

    Anyone who doubts Obama is a citizen, this is a blanket statement for you:

    Stop. Being. Dumbasses.

  29. Jim…that’s actually three statements….Hillary has two “l”s…alright, just kidding…..but anyway, what part of the govt had no doubt about his citizenship? And who is they? The one who spread the seeds? Who knows where the Messiah was born, I don’t…..but he’s not doing himself any favors by putting a computer generated certification of live birth instead of, oh let’s see, how about the original birth certificate?

  30. How about it’s a notarized copy.

    If there was any truth to it, do you not think Hillary or McCain would have had him removed from eligibility? Don’t you think Bush would have stopped the person who’s going to revoke or reverse all of his (bad) decisions?

    There is NO truth to it whatsoever.

    Also, you aren’t a Christian or Jewish are you? Kinda blasphemous referring to Obama as the Messiah.

  31. Yeah, you might be right, but actually, I was just using the nickname his good friend Louie Farrakhan gave him….it just sort of stuck…..Oprah calls him “the one”…….

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pB-_qUHe3HU

  32. Goodnight everyone…it’s been fun…Live Free or Die!

  33. Ugh. Farrakhan.

    Equal Ugh, Oprah.

  34. Yes. Alan Keyes is crazy.

  35. Jim, you say it’s notarized? I’m a notary, and I see no signature or notary stamp on his certificate. I have a friend who was born in Hawaii. His birth certificate looks nothing like this one.

  36. Natural-Born citizen=parents are U.S citizens, no matters where the child is born,John McCain,Panama.Rudy G.of N.Y.C BORN in Sicily,parents are U.S citizens.I think Ann DUNHAM WAS A U.S CITIZEN.By the way the children of illegal aliens born in this country, can run for President too…

  37. Keyes’ petition says that the statement by the head of the Hawaii State Department of Health that she had “personally seen and verified that the Hawaii State Department of Health has Senator Obama’s original birth certificate on record in accordance with state policies and procedures” is insufficient proof of Obama’s citizenship.

    Give it a rest – Obama was born in Hawaii

    Posted by charles grashow
    November 19th, 2008 at 10:36 am
  38. These are the exact kind of attacks that kill the Republican party in 21st century America

    So if you want to keep losing

    KEEP IT UP………………….

  39. Sorry Jim….they’re Barry’s friends, not mine….and before you go off on how Louie is not a BO associate, remember that Barry went to his million man march & Barry’s church gave Louie a lifetime acheivment award, BEFORE Barry had to quit for political reasons……

  40. Ahhhh, and so it begins: The Republican war on America.

    Again.

    Is Ken Starr going to be trotted out again to create mountains out of molehills? Maybe the Obamas have an unpaid parking ticket that will result in hours of testimony, dirt-digging, and millions of dollars in Republicans’ pockets?

    You can hear the cracking, as Republicans do deep-knee bends, getting ready to kick sand in our faces…All–over–again.

    I guess this is where the lack of integrity, intelligence and creativity has taken the GOP.

  41. What in the world does Farrakhan have to do with anything?

    From the Jewish Forward:

    Indeed, way back in 1995, the young Obama told the Chicago Reader:

    ”…Historically, African-Americans have turned inward and towards black nationalism whenever they have a sense, as we do now, that the mainstream has rebuffed us, and that white Americans couldn’t care less about the profound problems African-Americans are facing.”

    “But cursing out white folks is not going to get the job done. Anti-Semitic and anti-Asian statements are not going to lift us up….”

    Between Bush and some of his nefarious associations, Keating, G Gordon Liddy, Oliver North, Rush Limbaugh using his maid to score drugs, Hannity and Hal Turner, and broadcasting outside of Terri Shivo’s Hospice, these guys on the right have NO moral high ground, to throw stones at ANYBODY from.

  42. Jim, you say it’s notarized? I’m a notary, and I see no signature or notary stamp on his certificate. I have a friend who was born in Hawaii. His birth certificate looks nothing like this one.

    I was born in Texas, and the current copy of my birth certificate doesn’t look like my original either. And you can barely see the notary seal on my copy (though you can feel it) what are you expecting to see on a low resolution picture? What I can see is a faint line in the lower corner that looks like a notary cert # line from a typical stamp. I would dig mine out but I can’t be arsed to do that over something stupid like this.

    Posted by Joe the Skinhead
    November 19th, 2008 at 1:19 pm
  43. Gary,

    That’s EXACTLY what the liberals say about your side, except you believe in welfare for millionaires and billionaires.

    And why didn’t Bush run on war with Iraq, instead of ‘No nation building’?

  44. They demand to see his so-called ‘vault (original hospital) birth records’. If ‘they’ don’t think the official Certificate of Live Birth issued by the state of Hawaii is proof enough, why would they feel a hospital record is any better? It’s too easy to forge an offical state record, but a hospital record is impervious to forgery?

    I guarantee if Obama provided a ‘hospital document’ of his birth – people would immediately claim it was a forgery.

    Posted by Hope for Change
    November 19th, 2008 at 1:24 pm
  45. Gary sounds like he’s whinning.

  46. I’d personally be pretty pissed off if the hospital allowed someone to see my birth certificate randomly. With all the identity theft and whatnot going around these days.

    Posted by Jim from Jersey
    November 19th, 2008 at 1:35 pm
  47. Gary: “I am sick and tired of hearing you whiney liberal punks cryinbg about the war in Iraq! its war people are going to die.”

    Then get busy enlisting to get your a** shot off, Gary, since it’s so great. Stop whining about whiney liberals and put your dogtag where your mouth is.

  48. This is the same as all the nonsense about the Clintons.

    The right wing’s shtic has always been victimization of the ‘regular Americans’ by an elite liberal boogeyman.

  49. Hawaii birth certificates of the early 60s era had the notary seal on the back side.

  50. READ AND WEEP RIGHT WING LOONS.

    http://whatreallyhappened.com/WRHARTICLES/obamabirth.php

  51. Hi, Alan … use images at factceck.org of the birth certificate. These are higher resolution images and show the raised seal.

    http://www.factcheck.org/elections-2008/born_in_the_usa.html

  52. I say only people like me may be president. Natural born citizens with ancestry in the US that predates its independence.

    Muahahahaha!

    What, your ancestors came with John Smith and helped found Jamestown?

    *Turns head.*

    But you say you are a full blooded Native American?

    Oh, damn you all to hell!

  53. The short bus just pulled up and Keyes got off. He thought it was his campaign bus. The driver is laughing too hard to leave.

    Posted by Robert Blair
    November 19th, 2008 at 5:24 pm
  54. To all thinking people out there: These radical right-wing kooks all deny that Hawaii is a state. This is why these people won’t give up Obama hating.

  55. Yes. Alan Keyes is crazy and he is also someone who refuses to reconcile with his daughter. He kicked his daughter out of his house because she told him she likes girls. He kicked her out and told her to never come back. Isn’t he just full of love!

  56. He is still pissed that he lost to OBAMA for senate race in ILL.

  57. I can’t wait to come back to this forum in two years, after Hussein Obama gets done doin this country “dogie-style”. The morons who voted for this guy will all be eating crow.

    Posted by Steve Gentry
    November 19th, 2008 at 9:29 pm
  58. Excerpts from the “Petition for Writ of Mandate” (line 12, page 14): “This matter is currently being reviewed by the U.S.Supreme Court.” Thank you Dr. Keyes for standing up. I’ll wait for the decision. Meanwhile guys if you haven’t read this article yet, click
    http://www.itooktheredpill.wordpress.com/2008/11/04/whos-your-daddy-2/

  59. So now KOOK righites are ignoring actual birth announcements from TWO seperate Hawaii newspapers from 47 years ago. LOL

    Do the far rigites have any idea what fools they are?s

    I guess the Obama’s said to each other back in 1961, “little Barack might run for President in 2008 so we better plant a couple of bogus birth announcements in the newspapers in Hawaii.” LOL

    Posted by Daniel Torluemke
    November 20th, 2008 at 12:55 am
  60. As a Katrina survivor, I can tell you that the it was common knowledge that the levees would not hold if the city of New Orleans took a direct hit from a hurricane. The mayor knew it, the governor knew it and the Clinton Administration knew it. Stop blaming “W”. He helped us recoup our losses. The real criminals are the insurance companies. Very gratefully helped & relocated by the federal government–S.K.

  61. your buddy Dan from NH:
    You’re right! What was I thinking? Bush did nothing wrong. Just like the tanking economy is all in my head and I’m a whiner!

    Just look at poor Charles Manson, an innocent man sitting in jail! How do I know he’s innocent? Because he said so!

    Wake up, Bro.

  62. Keyes, your envy is showing.
    Now go pick up your 30 pieces of silver!

  63. Subject: FOI request for Obama’s birth certificate –found on the internet at http://www.DailyJeff.com-has all 50 SOS emails-1 stop emailing!

    FOI REQUEST TO ALL SOS FOR OBAMA’S BIRTH CERTIFICATE
    We need to find out what the SOS of the various States know about Obama’s birth certificate and qualifications to be president. If you have time, please send/fax/email the following FOI (freedom of information letter) to some or all of the SOS bureau of elections. After you get a response please post on http://www.obamacrimes.com, http://www.freerepublic.com, http://www.peoplespassions.org, http://americamustknow.com,www.rallycongress.com.
    1. The address , fax number and email address for the Bureau of elections for the states are at http://www.eac.gov.
    2. I like the faxes because they will respond quicker to them. Print off your generic FOI request and past/tape the next name over the top and fax it off. See emails listed below for all 50 SOS.Cut and paste to send all 50 at one time. Sit back and wait for answers.

    November 21, 2008
    TO: BUREAU OF ELECTIONS
    Bureau of Elections, California
    1500 11th St, 5th Floor FAX: 916-653-5634
    Sacramento, CA 95814 Email: elections@sos.ca.gov

    ATTN: Freedom of Information Officer
    REF: Freedom of Information Act Request/Privacy Act/ Open Meeting Act, Common Law
    This is a request under the Freedom of Information Act. Please send the following documents for examining and photocopying:
    1. Documents that show that Barack Obama is qualified to be President of the United States , including but not limited to:
    a. Original birth certificate
    b. Proof that he is a natural born United States citizen
    c. Proof that he was born in Kenya
    AS you know , the FOIA provides that if a portions of a document are exempt from release, the remainder must be segregated and disclosed. Therefore, I would like to examine all nonexempt portions of the records that I requested and I ask that you justify and deletions by citing specific exemptions of the FOIA
    This is a continuing request into the future for 6 months.
    If this is not the proper department, please forward to the Election Bureau/SOS.
    I promise to pay reasonable search and duplication fees in connection with this request. (Note: The FOIA permit some fee reduction or waivers).
    Please notify me if the charges will exceed ($20.00), so that I can decide whether to authorize a higher amount.
    Thank you for your assistance, I look forward to receiving your reply within five business days, as required by law.

    Sincerely,
    Robert Johnson
    123 Main St
    Anywhere , CA

    Cc: Clerk of the US Supreme Court
    One First Street N.E.
    Washington, DC 20543
    FAX: (209) 479-3021

    WARNING
    Should any person try to cover up this request or documents herein, BE YOU HEREBY PUT ON NOTICE: You may be indicted under USC Title 18 Sec. 3. 4, 2381, 2382, 2383, and 2384. Also, 4 U.S.C. & 101, federal law requires all state employees and officers take an oath of office and records kept of such administered oath.

    Jeannie.price@sos.alabama.gov,governor@alaska.gov,governorsoffice@asg-gov.net,

    sosadmin@azsos.gov,sos@sosmail.state.ar.us,constituentaffairs@sos.ca.gov,

    secretary@state.co.us ,susan.bysiewicz@po.state.ct.us ,lorilee.harrison@state.de.us ,

    Stephanie.scott@dc.gov,secretaryofstate@dos.state.fl.us,sosweb@sos.state.ga.us,

    elections@aloha.net,sosinfo@sos.idaho.gov,JWhite@ilos.net,

    constituentservices@sos.in.gov,sos@sos.state.ia.us,kssos@kssos.org,sos.secretary@ky.gov,

    bobby.jindal@la.gov,sos.office@maine.gov,bmorris@sos.state.md.us,

    agoweb@state.ma.us,secretary@michigan.gov,secretary.state@state.mn.us,

    administrator@sos.state.ms.us,sosmain@sos.mo.gov,sos@mt.gov,receptionist@sos.ne.gov,

    sosmail@sos.nv.gov,elections@sos.state.nh.us,feedback@sos.state.nj.us,

    nmsos@state.nm.us,info@dos.state.ny.us,emarshal@sosnc.com,sos@nd.gov,

    tworley@sos.state.oh.us,governor@gov.state.ok.us,Oregon.sos@state.or.us,

    pcortes@state.pa.us,correo@fortaleza.gobierno.pr,comments@sec.state.ri.us,

    rdaggerhart@sos.sc.gov,sdsos@state.sd.us,phil.bredesen@state.tn.us,

    secretary@sos.state.tx.us,mshurtleff@utah.gov,dmarkowitz@sec.state.vt.us,

    justice@usvi.org,soc@governor.virginia.gov,mail@secstate.wa.gov,

    wvsos@wvsos.com,wigov@gov.state.wi.us,secofstate@state.wy.us,

    Posted by Don Maccank
    November 23rd, 2008 at 7:18 pm
  64. Obama’s “Born” Conspiracy

  65. Rathergate II Certification of Live Birth a clear forgery

  66. First, the facts:

    1) In Hawaii, a Birth Certificate is issued by hospitals and forwarded to officials.
    2) A “Certificate of Live Birth” is issued where the infant wasn’t born in a hospital. I.e., born at home or born out of the country.
    3) Obama would be a natural citizen IF born in the US OR born to American Parents outside the country (as was John McCain). However, if ONE parent is not an American, and he was born outside the country, then he is not a natural citizen.
    4) Anyone can post a birth announcement. It is also very common to post them in places the parents formerly lived. Obama’s doesn’t state where he was born and is thus irrelevant to this discussion.
    5) The Certificate of live birth on the Obama web site has been proven to be altered using Photoshop.
    6) Constitutionally, IF Obama were to be declared ineligible before being sworn in on January 20th, then the vice-president elect would be sowrn in as president. I.e., Joe Biden would become the 44th president.
    7) Historically, the requirement in the Constitution is believed to have been placed there solely to prohibit Alexander Hamilton from ever becoming president.
    8) The Alan Keyes lawsuit, if successful, would be quite different. It would prevent California Electors from voting for Obama. While CA’s 55 votes wouldn’t matter, other states might follow. In such a case, Democrats might not have enough votes to elect the president in the Electoral College and, like the 1800 election, the House of Representatives would then make the election. While I’d expect them to elect Joe Biden, the House is not bound to do so by any law. This scenario could be VERY interesting.

    So, IF Obama has nothing to hide, and in fact was born in a hospital in Hawaii as he has stated; Why is he (and the DNC) spending bundles of money to fight lawsuits when obtaining and presenting a Birth Certificate would cost less than $25.00? Noting the above possibilities for chaos, you’d think they would be rushing to Hawaii to obtain documents.

    Worse, there is some compelling evidence that Obama was adopted by his step-father and became a citizen of Indonesia. (School records, etc.) Thus, he might not be a citizen at all. Note that the U.S. does not allow dual citizenships. While other countries do, and some people retain their former passports, for an American to become a citizen of another country requires renouncing his American citizenship.

    Basically, for Obama not to put this to bed by presenting proper documentation reeks of secrecy, conspiracy and plain old political hoodwinking. Do we really want these sorts of actions by our president?

    Posted by Neal Watts
    November 30th, 2008 at 8:08 pm
  67. Neal Watts,
    While I agree with most of what you just posted, you are incorrect about this:

    3) Obama would be a natural citizen IF born in the US OR born to American Parents outside the country (as was John McCain).

    Even if born in Hawaii, Obama’s father was a British citizen, who by British law gave his son British citizenship at birth. Obama has admitted as much on his fight the smears web site.

    Now, the issue is that people who are dual citizens at birth are not “Natural Born” citizens. They have split allegiance to another country, which is exactly what the founders intended to prevent in the Commander-in-Chief of our armed services.

    In my opinion, the best discussion of the “Natural Born” citizen issue can be found at
    http://texasdarlin.wordpress.com

  68. You guys really enjoy listening to yourselves and working yourselves (and others) into a frenzy.

    Wouldn’t care usually, but the country’s in a crisis at the moment, so please stop picking your navels (and Obama’s).

    And if, as good American citizens, you can’t offer reasonable solutions to deal with the economy, health care, Iraq war, unemployment, and mortgage crisis, then please kindly shut the heck up until you can offer something more constructive than conspiracy theories laced with bitterness and hostility.

  69. Summary of all legal action challenging Obama/Soetoro on the Natural Born Citizen issue:

    America Must Know

  70. You’re Ken Starr, aren’t you, Red Pill? By all means, tie up the President-Elect for his entire term over red-tape, meaningless lawsuits that mean NOTHING in the grand scheme of American progress and prosperity.

    So proud of yourself, aren’t you.

    America can go to hell in a handbasket, but by George, let’s spend our concentration on minutiae that was proven, by Left AND Right source, to all be according to Hoyle.

  71. Hi Sarah, I’m back from “them thar hills” and almost lost my shirt! Just kidding! It was the best time losing my money. Time spent with my daughter was worth more than that.

    I don’t understand how some of these people can still think if Pres.-elect Obama is not a citizen, he could still be in the position he is in now. There’s too many factions(ie-republicans) that would not have allowed him to come this far if he were not a citizen.

  72. Sarah,

    The Supreme Court will either hear the case or decline to hear the case. Your scenario is valid only if the Court declines to hear the case AND Obama continues to refuse to provide his birth certificate. I.e., Obama has the power to prevent future discussions on this subject simply by presenting a certified copy of his birth certificate.

    Should the Court decline the case, the Constitutional question is left in limbo and demands that Obama provide a certified copy of his Birth Certificate will escalate.

    IF they hear it, there will be lots of news about it, whatever they decide UNLESS they sidestep the issue of clarifying natural citizenship. Excepting that sidestep, it will be over before inauguration day and the Constitutional question will be settled.

    Basically, we have a Constitutional crisis and will see whether the Supreme Court has any fortitude. I wouldn’t call that red tape.

    IF you check the events not covered by the mainstream media, you’ll find lawsuits in several states to require Obama to prove his citizenship before the electoral college meets to elect him president. (He hasn’t been elected, yet – remember the Nov. election doesn’t elect the president and vice-president. The Nov. election selects the electors). E.g., Alan Keyes has filed suit in CA to prevent the casting of electoral votes until the issue is settled.

    Constitutional questions are common. The 1800 election was an electoral tie and went to Congress. It took 33 votes before Thomas Jefferson was elected president over Aaron Burr who became vice-president.

    Posted by Neal Watts
    December 5th, 2008 at 9:15 pm
  73. [...] this will put to rest these crazy attempts to deny Obama the presidency and allow the country to get on with the business of straightening out [...]

  74. Alan Colmes’ Liberaland posted: “[...] this will put to rest these crazy attempts to deny Obama the presidency and allow the country to get with the business of straigtening out [...]“.
    Not so fast. We’ll get there. Like I have mentioned in my previous comments “the matter is currently being reviewed by the U.S. Supreme Court”. It’s not about the ‘crazy attempts to deny Obama the presidency’. It’s about the Constitution. It’s up to the U.S. Supreme Court to decide. Let’s wait.

    Posted by Rudy Olaso
    December 8th, 2008 at 11:16 pm
  75. January 9th will be an interesting day, no matter how the U.S. Supreme Court rules.

  76. All of this is totally unnecessary. I see people looking like fools on both sides of the argument. From what I have seen, I would venture to say that President Elect Obama was more than likely born in Hawaii. On the other hand, I still agree that it is really odd that rather than just get the document and make it available, the Obama campaign tried to bury it. Why not just put it all out in the open and be done with it? The media is not without blame in this either. Digging up all the dirt they can on McCain/Palin that they can find (not to mention Joe the plumber) but they wouldn’t touch this one (because they were afraid it might prove to be true?) and instead just constantly sidestepped it and then after a while had passed of doing nothing indicated that we were beating a dead horse saying that it had already been settled. I don’t understand any of this. If we would all just be open and honest, this would not have happened.

    [ Gary: “I am sick and tired of hearing you whiney liberal punks cryinbg about the war in Iraq! its war people are going to die.”

    Then get busy enlisting to get your a** shot off, Gary, since it’s so great. Stop whining about whiney liberals and put your dogtag where your mouth is.]

    I agree on this one. Spend some time on the front lines and then come back and argue the point. I would also like to know, if President Bush was after the Iraqi oil, why are we not getting any of it?

  77. One more question: I keep hearing people calling PRESIDENT Bush a liar because we went into Iraq after wmd’s and didn’t find them. When there was ample opportunity to sneak them out of the country, how do we know that wmd’s were never in Iraq? We know some were used there so how is it so hard to imagine that they were simply hidden or moved?

  78. General Georges Sada, of the Iraqi Air Force under Saddam states in his book, “Saddam’s Secrets” that Fifty-Six (56) plane loads of WMD’s were shipped to Syria before the invasion, plus an unknown number of truckloads. He names the principals in the transactions and states he gave the coalition forces names of the pilots and other particulars.

    Most in the intelligence community believe the three 18 wheelers loaded with cash (dollars, Euros, etc.)which disappeared during the invasion actually was payment to Syria for storing the WMD’s.

    Further, the 20 tons of chemical materials, including nerve gas and blistering agents, used by Al Zarqawi to construct a chemical bomb in Amman, Jordan must have come from this stockpile. Jordanian intelligence (Mukhabarat) who uncovered the plot on April 26, 2004, stated that had this bomb been exploded, up to 60,000 Jordanians might have been killed.

    Posted by Neal Watts
    January 6th, 2009 at 11:08 pm