Could Sotomayor Save Privacy For Americns?
It was Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor whose opinion in U.S. v Jones, a case that involved the use of a GPS device on a suspect’s car, that Judge Richard Leon relied on last week to rule part of the NSA program unconstitutional. It was Sotomayor’s lonely concurrence that had the White House talking about scaling back the NSA’s spying.
It may be necessary to reconsider the premise that an individual has no reasonable expectation of privacy in information voluntarily disclosed to third parties,” Sotomayor wrote in 2012. “This approach is ill suited to the digital age, in which people reveal a great deal of information about themselves to third parties in the course of carrying out mundane tasks.”
Not a single other member of the high court signed onto Sotomayor’s concurrence; her three Democratic appointed colleagues sided with a narrower one written by Justice Samuel Alito. Though all nine justices agreed that police would likely need to get a warrant to place a GPS device on a suspect’s car, it was Sotomayor who was willing to argue that modern technology had essentially changed the meaning of what privacy means when so much of our personal information and history is preserved online, and can be easily collected by the government in mass quantities. When the Framers of the Constitution wrote of “persons, houses, papers, and effects,” they could not have imagined cloud storage or cell phone location tracking.
Now read this:
- U.S. Spied On German Media And Government (Jul 3, 2015)
- Cruz: Ignore Supreme Court On Gay Marriage (Jun 30, 2015)
- Supreme Court Blocks Texas’s Restrictive Abortion Rules (Jun 29, 2015)
- SCOTUS Votes For Pollution (Jun 29, 2015)
- SCOTUS: Controversial Drug Can Be Used In Executions (Jun 29, 2015)
- SCOTUS: States Can’t Ask For Proof Of Citizenship During Voter Registration (Jun 29, 2015)
Alan Colmes is the publisher of Liberaland.
Our Readers Say ...
Hot Off The Liberaland Press…
- Sanders Responds To Criticism That He’s ‘Too Liberal’
- 8 Dead, 41 Wounded With Weekend Chicago Gun Violence
- Former RNC Chair To Republicans: Condemn Trump
- Sex, Drugs, And High Finance
- Maine Man Dies Trying To Launch Firework From Top Of His Head
- Chip Off The Old Trump–Santorum Claims Immigrants Come Illegally ‘With A Bad Intent’
- The Donald Quadruples Down On ‘Crimes’ Of ‘Illegal Immigrants’